Monday, 6 December 2010

Nicotine based smoking cessation treatments available to Scottish children

This is not a new story: nicotine replacement therapies have been approved for people as young as 12 since 2005. General Practitioners in Scotland were sent updates on good practice in 2007, in order to remind doctors that, following research, NRT was considered safe for 12–18-year-olds and pregnant women as well as other adults.

I came across this story when the Herald reported it in 2007. I wrote it up here (the link to the Herald story is at the foot of the page), and it is clear that the comments (mostly very critical of prescribing NRT to young people) have been edited out.

Two of the people mentioned in the Herald piece, Linda Bauld and John Britton are both leading figures in tobacco control, involved with the UK Centre for Tobacco Control Studies. Their interest in tobacco control as a growing concept is clear, even though they don't have direct personal commercial interest in nicotine products.

Recommending nicotine for young people doesn't seem sound to me but not being a medic I'm not in a position to make detailed comment.  However, I don't like the fact that comments have been censored from the Herald article (the words '0 comments' imply that no comments were ever made, which is patently false).

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure exactly what you mean whaen you say that John Britton doesn't have a direct commercial interest in nicotine products. See, just for one example of many, the Competing Interests at the end of this paper.

http://thorax.bmj.com/content/early/2008/02/08/thx.2007.090647.full.pdf

Belinda said...

Anon:

I should have said according to the information on the UKCTCS link he does not appear to have direct commercial interests in nicotine. Thanks for this link.

Anonymous said...

Linda Bauld mentioned in this:-

http://www.nice.org.uk/media/31F/BB/PHIAC21Minutes180108.pdf

Xopher said...

A couple of years ago I worked in the same building as a local youth club and their 'legal high' was gained by getting NRT
AND having a fag - law of unintended consequences
BUT these kids probably showed on the 'quitters through smoking cessation figures'.
Quitters my arse - they were taking the piss out of the do-gooders - can you blame them?

Xopher said...

PS. I should have mentioned that I met some of them during the summer and 2 had given up smoking - They'd listened to what I'd said.
Strange that those with the most relevant advice cannot be 'stakeholders' nor can they be allowed any place in discussion!
Obviously not 'cos we're told that (the non-existent) 'discussion is over'!